best Indestructibe Toys for dogs
Updated November 2020
Why Trust MyDogWantsThat?
Here at MDWT, you can trust that you’re getting the best information for your dog, because we’re dog owners ourselves. We carefully assess the best (and worst) dog products on the market, giving you a full breakdown of what’s out there so you as an owner can make informed choices when it comes to your dog.
Why Trust MyDogWantsThat?
Here at MDWT, you can trust that you’re getting the best information for your dog, because we’re dog owners ourselves. We carefully assess the best (and worst) dog products on the market, giving you a full breakdown of what’s out there so you as an owner can make informed choices when it comes to your dog.
- As Good As It Gets
- Best On A Budget
Bottom Line
Currently the most durable dog ball available, this toy is designed to survive even the most extreme chewers.
Made out of durable nylon, this flavored toy is made for small power chewers and promotes dental health.
This dog bone chew toy can be both enjoyed on dry land or in water. It’s made of safe recycled materials.
A flavored chew toy made of tough nylon material that comes in a shape familiar to dogs.
Shaped like a soda can, this rubber toy dispenses treats to add mental stimulation. It’s a good combination of mental and physical exercise.
Pros
Puncture-resistant.
Reliable Kong quality.
Very bouncy.
Inexpensive.
Cleans the teeth and gums while chewing.
Durable.
Great price.
Doubles as a fetch stick.
Easy to clean.
Bright attractive colors.
Comes with a 100% guarantee against damage.
Made with natural flavors.
Excellent durability.
Donates part of sales to dog welfare organizations.
FDA compliant.
Holds up well against hard chewers.
Doubles as a reward-based toy to fight off boredom.
Good price.
Cons
t’s still possible for some dogs to destroy it but holds up well most of the time.
For small breeds only.
Some dogs aren’t enticed by the flavor.
A little more expensive.
Durability isn’t as advertised.
Too tough for some pups.
Can break teeth of smaller dogs or puppies.
The Hole is too small for some treats.
Size is smaller than expected.
Some dogs will still be able to break it.
- As Good As It Gets
KONG - Extreme Ball - Durable Rubber Dog Toy for Power Chewers, Black
Bottom Line
Currently the most durable dog ball available, this toy is designed to survive even the most extreme chewers.
Pros
Puncture-resistant.
Reliable Kong quality.
Very bouncy.
Inexpensive.
Cons
t’s still possible for some dogs to destroy it but holds up well most of the time.
- Best On A Budget
Nylabone Power Chew Textured Dog Chew Ring Toy
Bottom Line
Made out of durable nylon, this flavored toy is made for small power chewers and promotes dental health.
Pros
Cleans the teeth and gums while chewing.
Durable.
Great price.
Cons
For small breeds only.
Some dogs aren’t enticed by the flavor.
WEST PAW Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone Chew Toy
Bottom Line
This dog bone chew toy can be both enjoyed on dry land or in water. It’s made of safe recycled materials.
Pros
Doubles as a fetch stick.
Easy to clean.
Bright attractive colors.
Comes with a 100% guarantee against damage.
Cons
A little more expensive.
Durability isn’t as advertised.
Benebone Real Bacon Durable Wishbone Dog Chew Toy
Bottom Line
A flavored chew toy made of tough nylon material that comes in a shape familiar to dogs.
Pros
Made with natural flavors.
Excellent durability.
Donates part of sales to dog welfare organizations.
Cons
Too tough for some pups.
Can break teeth of smaller dogs or puppies.
SodaPup Dog Chew Toy and Treat Dispenser
Bottom Line
Shaped like a soda can, this rubber toy dispenses treats to add mental stimulation. It’s a good combination of mental and physical exercise.
Pros
FDA compliant.
Holds up well against hard chewers.
Doubles as a reward-based toy to fight off boredom.
Good price.
Cons
The Hole is too small for some treats.
Size is smaller than expected.
Some dogs will still be able to break it.
How We Decided
The only way to decide which toys are indestructible is to test them! So we let the MDWT pups test the durability and fun factor of these toys. We also scoured the internet for reviews and feedback from other pet parents. Here’s how we decided:
23
Models Considered
8
Hours Researched
1
Experts Interviewed
5
Consumer Consulted
Buying Guide For The Best Indestructible Toys for Dogs
Some dogs are heavier chewer than others and standard toys won’t last a day. For these dogs, indestructible toys are your best bet. These toys come in different designs but are all made to satisfy your dog’s prehistoric chewing instincts.
But more than this, getting your dog toys to chew on or play with prevents boredom and helps your dog stay calm especially when you need to leave them alone. When getting indestructible toys, durability is the selling point that these toys need to deliver. However, keep in mind that there is no truly indestructible toy. All toys will wear out eventually, the best ones just last longer.
The best indestructible toys are tough and very durable and are meant to entertain your dog for hours. They’re usually made of rubber, plastic, or tough nylon or rope. There are other materials available, but these are the most durable ones on the market. Whichever you’re going for, make sure to inspect that they’re non-toxic and safe.
They also come in different shapes like dog bones, spheres, sticks, and a lot more. Even better, some are flavored, making chew time a yummier experience.
But before checking out of the counter, make sure you’re getting the size and toughness appropriate for your dog. Some toys have toughness levels that fit your dog’s chewing behavior. Your dog might end up losing some teeth if you get something too hard.
Buying Guide For The Best Indestructible Toys for Dogs
Some dogs are heavier chewer than others and standard toys won’t last a day. For these dogs, indestructible toys are your best bet. These toys come in different designs but are all made to satisfy your dog’s prehistoric chewing instincts.
But more than this, getting your dog toys to chew on or play with prevents boredom and helps your dog stay calm especially when you need to leave them alone. When getting indestructible toys, durability is the selling point that these toys need to deliver. However, keep in mind that there is no truly indestructible toy. All toys will wear out eventually, the best ones just last longer.
The best indestructible toys are tough and very durable and are meant to entertain your dog for hours. They’re usually made of rubber, plastic, or tough nylon or rope. There are other materials available, but these are the most durable ones on the market. Whichever you’re going for, make sure to inspect that they’re non-toxic and safe.
They also come in different shapes like dog bones, spheres, sticks, and a lot more. Even better, some are flavored, making chew time a yummier experience.
But before checking out of the counter, make sure you’re getting the size and toughness appropriate for your dog. Some toys have toughness levels that fit your dog’s chewing behavior. Your dog might end up losing some teeth if you get something too hard.
Key Considerations
Caution
Regularly clean your dog’s toys. Chew toys become wet with saliva and are left on the floor, becoming home to bacteria and other unwanted microbes. These can cause health problems for your dog, as well as spread them across your home.
Indestructible Toys for Dogs Features
The most important feature of these toys is their enhanced durability. They’re made to be chewed on and last as long as possible. But aside from this, they can also double as another toy for another game or exercise.
Some toys are shaped like a disc to be used to play frisbee, some are balls or sticks made to double as a fetch toy, while other rope toys can be used to play tug of war. So if you’re looking for a multi-purpose toy, look for those added features.
Another great feature of tough chew toys is dental benefits. Some products can clean your dog’s teeth and gums as they play and chew. It’s not just fun, it gives them good dental health too.
To keep your dog engaged, some toys are flavored. Bacon, chicken, beef, and other flavors make it more enjoyable to chew on the toy.
Expert Tip
Whenever you give your dog a new toy, inspect it each time after they play with it. Check for any damage or if it has been destroyed and needs to be discarded. Look for anything that can pose any danger before letting them play with it again.
Indestructible Toys for Dogs Prices
Indestructible toys come at a premium because of their extreme durability. So expect their prices to be higher than toys of the same kind but aren’t made for heavy chewers. But most of the time, the premium is worth it.
If your dog is an aggressive chewer, don’t try to think you’ll be able to save by getting a cheap chew toy. It won’t last a day and you’ll end up spending on another toy.
However, not all indestructible toys are as tough as advertised. Check reviews to find out if these are as tough they claim to be. To get great value, it’s recommended to purchase from known brands that have an excellent track record of making highly durable chew toys.
Tips
- Supervise your dog’s playtime with their new toy for a week or so. This is to make sure that the toy is as durable as it’s supposed to be.
- Puppies that are teething require a different kind of toy. Giving them extremely tough toys might end up breaking their teeth.
- Be careful with sharing toys if you have multiple dogs. Some dogs can become possessive and toy sharing can lead to a fight.
- Keep away from toys made of wood or those with abrasive surfaces. These can potentially injure your dog’s mouth and gums.
other products we Considered
Looking for more variety? Here are a couple of chew toys made for power chewers that are still recommended even if they didn’t make our list.
Bone-ified Dog Chews. Cut from real deer antlers, this chew toy are rich in nutrients and are effective in reducing separation anxiety,
Goughnuts Indestructible Chew Toy MAXX. A chew stick made of extremely durable materials. The 11-inch toy has a visual safety indicator, perfect for large breeds.
FAQ's
Why do dogs chew on things?
There are multiple reasons for chewing. Young pups chew because they’re teething and chewing reduces pain while older dogs chew to keep teeth clean. But more importantly, dogs chew to combat boredom and it relieves anxiety and even frustration.
Are indestructible toys tough enough for aggressive chewers?
Indestructible toys are made to be strong enough to withstand power chewers. However, the constant punishment will still deteriorate the quality of the toy. It’s just a question of how long it will last. So when buying these toys, look for the brands that offer the best quality based on real-life use.
The Team That WOrked on This Review
Nitin Gupta
Chief Content Officer
JJ Resnick
Director of Growth
Erik Adler
Editorial Director